I doubt that I am the only one to ever have this question: "Why doesn't the Bible have its own internal dictionary?" For the English language there are a host of dictionaries available to consult, if a person does not understand a particular word. Why does the Bible lack the tool of its own internal reliable dictionary? But what if it does have one? What if we are looking for the wrong kind of dictionary?
Using the example of dictionaries for the English language, the majority are written in a format where words define other words. Good examples are: Webster's New World Dictionary and Black's Law Dictionary. But there are dictionaries that follow a different format. I could point out a host of them on-line, but for my examples I'd like to look at my own dictionary shelf. It contains The Dictionary of Cultural Literacy, The Magic World of Words: A Very First Dictionary, and Ultimate Visual Dictionary. For my purposes, I want to point out that the last two use illustrations or pictures as a primary way to define words. This raises the question whether the Bible could have its own format for a dictionary that does not follow only the format of words defining words. It doesn't use pictures either, but this does not rule out word pictures.
A number of years ago I ran across a scholarly article that ruled out the idea that the Hebrew words zedekah (translated as righteousness) and mishpat (translated as justice or judgment depending on the context) are synonymous. I mentioned this to a Christian teacher, who travels worldwide, and when he tried to present the same idea in Germany, Lutherans there protested that Luther saw them as synonymous. So how are we to solve this problem?
The first clue came for me from my experience of working in carpentry and reading in Isaiah that righteousness is like the plumb line while justice is like the horizontal leveling line. The top picture of a plumb line level combo is especially relevant, since it is very similar to the tool thought to have been used in building the pyramids in Egypt.
Since that time I have read a similar comparison from the context of streams and rivers found in the book of Amos. Here's one way it is translated:
This is no surprise, since he was previously a shepherd and would have needed to water his flocks. Finally, I recently ran across another example of comparison using the example of light in Psalm 37. This comparison comes the field of astronomy or from the observation of daylight
Another easy way to think of the distinction between righteousness and justice is to think of the difference between the answers to two similar, yet different questions. They are:
How many? (Quantity)
How much? (Quality)
Note here that the quantity is this passage is: "light" as one, but it also has a quality: "As the noonday [light]". The difference between the two things are clear since the comparisons are not exactly the same. The point is their difference though they are both measures or amounts. Can you clearly see this? "Light" and "noonday" are distinct and not synonymous though related.
FINALLY, a light shone brightly in my own mind. What if the Bible instead of defining words by other words, defines words by concrete comparisons that are well-known?
This also explains Jesus' motivation with parables to insure people understood the meaning of his words. It also agrees with the concept that I learned years ago that a knower and a teacher are distinct from each other and also a complement to each other. The knower is focused on experience or the referent (thing referred to in communication) and the teacher is focused on words. Ideally in communication the two work in tandem. It would seem that the Bible's definitions for righteousness and justice do just that. It ties the real world to the vocabulary world.
So now part of my task is to find the contexts that connect Yahweh and holy to a comparison much as righteousness and justice are compared to no less than three concrete things. This is now a critical part of my quest for a definitive definition for holy. May the righteous and just God of all eternity bless your day.
In Christ,
Jon
Showing posts with label teacher. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teacher. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
Holy: Understanding it Better As Knowers and Teachers
This is one of those entries where I need to say something about my other closely related blog on communication basics 101. It is largely the best tool I can recommend for getting at the basics of meaning, as it relates to the meaning of holy. When it all comes down to meaning, holy is likely one of five major classes of meaning or at least one class is primary.
So if you want to understand those classes better, please check out my most recent entry:
http://communicationbasics101.blogspot.com/2012/11/communication-basics-word-meanings-of.html and some of the earlier ones in that same blog.
They are very helpful for keeping things as basic as possible, but they also are categories that are supported within the scholarly community of translators, linguists and teachers. The classes of meaning have credibility and credibility is what I try to add a little more of, in my latest entry.
Please examine the entry and then for yourself decide which one of the five meaning classes you think holy falls into as a word that posses meaning. Another challenge would be to take the different definitions that are possible and ask yourself as one example, if "set apart" or if "whole" falls into one or more of these basic meaning classes and which one is primary.
Theologians sometimes mingle these basic meanings, when it comes to "set apart", so see if you can figure out which meaning is primary or not. Test this method for yourself. You do not need to be an expert or scholar to test your knowledge. It will not make you a scholar, but it can make you knower. Enjoy!
In Christ,
Jon
So if you want to understand those classes better, please check out my most recent entry:
http://communicationbasics101.blogspot.com/2012/11/communication-basics-word-meanings-of.html and some of the earlier ones in that same blog.
They are very helpful for keeping things as basic as possible, but they also are categories that are supported within the scholarly community of translators, linguists and teachers. The classes of meaning have credibility and credibility is what I try to add a little more of, in my latest entry.
Please examine the entry and then for yourself decide which one of the five meaning classes you think holy falls into as a word that posses meaning. Another challenge would be to take the different definitions that are possible and ask yourself as one example, if "set apart" or if "whole" falls into one or more of these basic meaning classes and which one is primary.
Theologians sometimes mingle these basic meanings, when it comes to "set apart", so see if you can figure out which meaning is primary or not. Test this method for yourself. You do not need to be an expert or scholar to test your knowledge. It will not make you a scholar, but it can make you knower. Enjoy!
In Christ,
Jon
Labels:
classes,
classes of meaning,
communication,
communication basics,
define,
defines,
definition,
dictionary,
hagios,
holy,
knower,
learner,
meaning,
means,
qadosh,
set apart,
student,
studier,
teacher,
whole
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


